Notable Cases & Decisions

A look at the appellate victories, redevelopment challenges, and tax court decisions that have defined our practice. Each one reflects the work our attorneys put in to protect the property rights of owners and businesses across New Jersey.

Orneta v. City of Plainfield

Carlin, Ward, Ash & Heiart LLC represented adjoining property owners in the challenge to a condemnation redevelopment area. The matter was quickly resolved once a complaint was filed and the City agreed to remove the properties from the condemnation redevelopment area.

Read More

Malanga v. Township of West Orange

On appeal, the appellate court overturned the decision of the trial court, and found that the record lacked adequate basis for finding that the property was a blighted redevelopment area.

Read More

In the matter of Bogota Redevelopment Area

Carlin, Ward, Ash & Heiart, LLC represented the interests of a tennis club when the municipality proposed including a portion of their assembled properties in a condemnation redevelopment area. Our attorneys successfully cross-examined the Borough’s planner resulting in the removal of our clients’ properties from the redevelopment area.

Read More

City of Long Branch v. Anzalone

The appellate court found that the Long Branch did not find actual blight under any subsection of the Local Redevelopment and Housing Law, that the record lacked substantial evidence that could have supported the New Jersey Constitution’s standard for finding blight, and that the absence of substantial evidence of blight...

Read More

Township of Bloomfield v. 110 Washington Street

The appellate court upheld the decision of the trial court, who dismissed the condemnation complaint and concluded that the record lacked adequate basis for finding that the defendant’s property was a blighted redevelopment area.

Read More

Suits & Deals

Record condemnation verdicts and settlements including jury and negotiated resolutions where our attorneys secured just compensation for property owners across New Jersey.

$60M Amtrak Condemnation Settlement

Amtrak v. Weehawken Property Owner

A Weehawken waterfront parcel was sold to Amtrak for $60 million after an eminent domain settlement secured by Carlin, Ward, Ash & Heiart — one of the largest condemnation settlements in New Jersey history.

Read More

$18.6M Condemnation Verdict

Jersey City Redevelopment Authority v. Kerrigan

A Hudson County jury awarded $18.6 million to the owner of 3.4 waterfront acres taken by the Jersey City Redevelopment Authority for a high-rise project. The authority offered $1.25 million,...

Read More

$5.15M Condemnation Settlement

New Jersey School Construction v. Ruggiero Seafood Co.

The New Jersey School Construction Co., a state fund that finances school development in urban districts under Abbott v. Burke, paid $5.15 million for a Newark seafood plant to build...

Read More

$3.2M Condemnation Settlement

Township of Livingston v. Zheng

The Township of Livingston acquired our client’s property for the location of a new Department of Public Works facility. After a commissioners’ hearing, a settlement was reached in which the...

Read More

$2M Condemnation Verdict

City of Linden v. Benedict Motel Corp.

A Union County jury awarded $2 million to a motel seeking compensation from the city of Linden for taking land for a road-widening project. The city originally offered $115,000 but...

Read More

$1M Condemnation Settlement

New Jersey Department of Transportation v. Dabb

Successfully negotiated a settlement with the State of New Jersey on behalf of the owner of a gas station impacted by a partial taking for a road widening project. The...

Read More

$1M Condemnation Settlement

New Jersey Department of Transportation v. 56 Rt 22, LLC

Our attorneys worked closely with an appraiser, planner, and engineer to establish a novel theory of damages for the partial taking and loss of parking for an automobile dealership. The...

Read More